← Back to Blog

Who Gets Paid When a Nonprofit Hospital Pays No Tax: Vendors, Executives, Bondholders, Managers and Insiders

· 16 min read Who Gets Paid When a Nonprofit Hospital Pays No Tax: Vendors, Executives, Bondholders, Managers and Insiders

The first post in this pair added up the public money under the biggest nonprofit hospital systems and medical charities: the tax exemption, the bond subsidy, the donor deduction, Medicare and Medicaid, research grants and state supplemental payments, plus portfolios that compound without tax. This one asks the next question. Once that money is inside the institution, who does it go to?

Most of it goes where you would hope. Nurses, doctors, technicians and support staff are the largest expense on every hospital return in the set, and that is the care. This post is about the other parties: the companies, managers, investors and insiders whose income depends on the tax-favored model itself. The same 26 returns from the first post, read from the IRS e-file data, name most of them. I give companies by name and people by title only, the way the filings list their pay.

Where each name comes from

Five parts of Form 990 do most of the work here:

  • Part VII Section B lists the five independent contractors paid the most, if they received more than $100,000, plus a count of every contractor over that line.
  • Schedule J breaks down pay for each officer, director and key employee over $150,000, including pay from related organizations, and asks yes or no questions about severance and supplemental retirement plans.
  • Part IX line 11f reports investment management fees the organization paid directly.
  • Schedule K lists each tax-exempt bond issue outstanding, with its issuer and original price.
  • Schedule L reports business deals, loans and family employment involving officers, directors, key employees and large donors. Schedule R lists related entities, including the taxable ones and the offshore ones.

One caution carries through every table. Schedule J includes pay from related organizations, so a system executive can appear on several returns from the same system. I never add figures across returns.

1. Vendors and contractors

The biggest single private payments in these filings go to taxable companies that sell services to the tax-exempt ones. Here is the largest contractor on each of the major returns.

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Filing entity Largest contractor (service as filed) Paid in the year Contractors paid over $100,000
CommonSpirit Health Conifer Health Solutions (revenue cycle services) $636.8M 301
Kaiser Foundation Hospitals Cardinal Health (consulting services) $537.0M 288
St. Jude Children's Research Hospital Flintco (construction) $283.6M 116
New York-Presbyterian Hospital Lendlease (construction services) $235.1M 223
Children's Hospital Colorado University of Colorado Medicine (physician services) $173.3M 141
Shriners Hospitals for Children CX Marketing (marketing) $118.7M 126
Sutter Health R1 RCM (healthcare financial services) $111.3M 561
Cleveland Clinic Foundation Qualivis (personnel services) $91.8M 626
Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System Barton Malow-Haselden (construction services) $49.1M 262
Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado Vascular Center of Colorado (medical services) $44.5M 177
PorterCare Adventist Health System South Denver Cardiology Associates (cardiology services) $41.7M 221
Trinity Health Leidos (IT consulting) $33.4M 490
Mass General Brigham KPMG (consulting services) $31.4M 186

Several kinds of business show up again and again.

Billing and collections. The largest contractor payment in the whole set is CommonSpirit's $636.8 million to Conifer Health Solutions, a revenue cycle company owned by Tenet Healthcare, a for-profit hospital chain. CommonSpirit held a 23.8 percent stake in Conifer under a 2012 outsourcing deal. In February 2026 the two sides agreed that CommonSpirit will pay Tenet about $1.9 billion over three years to end the services contract, and Conifer will pay CommonSpirit about $540 million for its stake (Tenet announcement; Fierce Healthcare). At Sutter, the top contractor is R1 RCM at $111.3 million. R1 was taken private by the private equity firms TowerBrook Capital Partners and Clayton, Dubilier & Rice in a deal valued at about $8.9 billion that closed on November 19, 2024 (R1 RCM). Turning a nonprofit hospital's bills into collected revenue is a large for-profit business, and private equity owns a good part of it.

Staffing. Rose International received $514.2 million from Kaiser's hospitals, AMN Healthcare $99.4 million from New York-Presbyterian, Aya Healthcare $98.7 million from Sutter, Qualivis $91.8 million from Cleveland Clinic, RightSourcing $59.5 million from Sutter and $48.7 million from the former SCL Health system, and Randstad Healthcare $20.0 million from Mass General Brigham.

Construction. Flintco received $283.6 million from St. Jude, Lendlease $235.1 million from New York-Presbyterian, Swinerton $203.1 million from Kaiser, Boldt $52.6 million from Sutter, and Turner Construction $44.3 million from Cleveland Clinic and $42.4 million from New York-Presbyterian.

Consultants, software and law firms. Kaiser paid Cardinal Health $537.0 million and Accenture International $234.0 million, both filed as consulting or business services, and Blackstone Consulting Inc. $363.3 million. CommonSpirit paid the law firm Polsinelli $43.8 million and McKinsey & Company $38.4 million. Trinity paid Leidos $33.4 million and Epic Systems $33.1 million. Ascension paid Ernst & Young $10.2 million and Kirkland & Ellis $7.3 million.

Physician groups. Children's Hospital Colorado paid University of Colorado Medicine $173.3 million for physician services. The two Colorado hospital companies run by CommonSpirit and AdventHealth paid US Anesthesia Partners of Colorado $17.6 million and $13.6 million. That anesthesia group was built with backing from the private equity firm Welsh, Carson, Anderson & Stowe. The Federal Trade Commission alleged that the firm, through US Anesthesia Partners, made acquisitions that suppressed competition and raised prices for anesthesia in Texas. Under a final 2025 consent order, the firm must limit its involvement with the group and get FTC approval before acquiring or investing in any anesthesia business (FTC).

Marketing and fundraising. Shriners paid CX Marketing $118.7 million, New York-Presbyterian paid Havas Media $29.1 million, Mass General Brigham paid Boathouse Group $21.3 million, and ALSAC, which raises money for St. Jude, paid InfoCision $8.6 million for call center work.

Two things are true at once. These are real services, and the companies pay tax on their profits. But their revenue comes from institutions whose prices, borrowing and reserves are subsidized, so the subsidy does not stop at the hospital door.

2. Executives

The first post showed the highest paid person on each return. Here is the whole Schedule J population on the largest returns: everyone the return lists, with total pay including deferred pay and benefits.

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Filing entity People on Schedule J Total Schedule J pay Base salary Bonus and incentive Bonus share of total
CommonSpirit Health 32 $128.6M $31.2M $73.1M 57%
Kaiser Foundation Hospitals 76 $122.6M $36.6M $49.8M 41%
New York-Presbyterian Hospital 37 $92.1M $29.2M $30.9M 34%
Advocate Health Care Network 24 $83.0M $11.4M $29.1M 35%
Mayo Clinic 62 $68.6M $53.8M $0.6M 1%
Ascension Health Alliance 18 $58.1M $10.7M $36.4M 63%
Cleveland Clinic Foundation 27 $57.3M $41.7M $0.1M under 1%
Sutter Health 28 $56.5M $17.1M $22.0M 39%
Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System 44 $52.0M $18.4M $8.0M 15%
Mass General Brigham 20 $50.1M $23.0M $15.1M 30%
Intermountain Health Care 22 $47.2M $15.5M $13.8M 29%

The split matters. Mayo Clinic and Cleveland Clinic pay their leaders almost entirely in salary. CommonSpirit and Ascension pay more in bonus than in salary across their whole executive group, and Ascension's group earned 63 cents of every dollar as incentive pay. A bonus tied to operating or financial targets rewards the margin, and the margin is where the tax exemption and the investment returns land. Intermountain shows another channel: $14.6 million of its Schedule J total was deferred pay.

The yes or no boxes fill in the rest. Of the 24 returns in the set with Schedule J entries, 16 checked the box for severance or change of control payments and 22 checked the box for a supplemental nonqualified retirement plan. Starting in 2026, every one of these employers owes a 21 percent excise tax on each employee's pay above $1 million, as the first post explains, and it pays that tax from the same tax-free revenue.

3. Money managers

Large portfolios need managers, and managers charge fees. These are the investment management fees the returns report paying directly:

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Filing entity Investment management fees paid (Part IX line 11f)
Kaiser Foundation Hospitals $82.7M
Howard Hughes Medical Institute $72.4M
Northwestern Memorial HealthCare $45.7M
UPMC (parent) $25.7M
Sutter Health $25.6M
Cleveland Clinic Foundation $22.3M
Shriners Hospitals for Children $19.7M
Ascension Health Alliance $13.6M
Trinity Health $11.9M
Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System $10.9M

Those figures understate the total. A private equity, hedge or credit fund usually takes its management fee and its share of profits, the carried interest, from inside the fund, so the investor's return arrives net and the fee never appears as a line on the investor's return. Schedule R names some of the funds: AQR, D. E. Shaw, Brigade and ICG vehicles on the Sutter return; Ellington, Whale Rock and Kerogen vehicles on Cleveland Clinic's; Ampfield, Blantyre, Linonia and LSV vehicles on the Howard Hughes return; Korea and Australia buyout partnerships on Intermountain's. The Ascension return even lists a Delaware entity whose name ends in "Blocker Corp", the structure the first post described.

Here is the asymmetry. The hospital, as the investor, pays no tax on its share of a fund's gains. The fund's managers pay tax on their carried interest at long-term capital gains rates, as long as the fund held the investment for more than three years, under section 1061 of the tax code (26 U.S.C. 1061). The managers' fees are ordinary income. So the tax-exempt pool is one of the reasons a manager's fee stream grows, and the manager's share of the profits is still taxed below wage rates. Howard Hughes makes the point inside its own walls: its best paid employee is its chief investment officer, and three of its top five contractors are investment managers.

4. Bondholders

The Treasury prices the tax exclusion on hospital construction bond interest at $3.59 billion in fiscal 2025 (Treasury tax expenditures, fiscal 2026). That money is federal tax the bond buyers do not pay. Hospitals gain from a lower interest rate, and the investors gain the exclusion itself. The Congressional Research Service explains who those investors are: benefits from tax-exempt bonds "are directly proportional to the investor's marginal tax rate, meaning that higher-income taxpayers benefit more from them than do lower-income taxpayers," and higher-income taxpayers also tend to have more capital to lend (CRS, IF12969).

Schedule K shows how much these systems have outstanding:

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Filing entity Bond issues listed Original issue price, total Tax-exempt bond liabilities (Part X)
Kaiser Foundation Hospitals 16 $9.58B $6.08B
CommonSpirit Health 15 $6.93B $4.12B
Trinity Health 37 $6.78B $4.66B
UPMC (parent) 27 $6.05B $4.59B
Ascension Health Alliance 13 $5.76B $5.47B
Intermountain Health Care 14 $5.33B $4.82B
Mass General Brigham 14 $5.29B $3.15B
Providence St. Joseph Health 19 $4.57B $2.49B
Cleveland Clinic Foundation 11 $3.80B $3.57B

The issuers are state and local conduit authorities, such as the California Statewide Communities Development Authority for Kaiser, the Illinois Finance Authority for Northwestern and Trinity, and the Colorado Health Facilities Authority for Children's Hospital Colorado, Intermountain and CommonSpirit. The authority lends its tax-exempt status. The hospital owes the debt, and the bondholders collect tax-free interest, while the same hospitals keep billions invested in stocks and private funds.

5. Captive insurers

Nearly every large system in the set owns an insurance company, and most of them are offshore. Schedule R lists, among others, Mayo Insurance Company, CCHS Indemnity (Cleveland Clinic), Trinity Assurance, Advocate Insurance SPC, Ascension Health Insurance Limited and Sunflower Assurance, Strategic and Physicians Insurance and First Initiatives Insurance (CommonSpirit), Mountain West Health Captive (Intermountain), Panther Reinsurance and Forbes Reinsurance (UPMC) and Insurance Casualty and Risk Enterprise (Kaiser), all in the Cayman Islands, plus New York-Presbyterian's Network Insurance Company in Bermuda.

Hospitals are the core of that market. The Cayman Islands Monetary Authority says the islands are "the second largest domicile for captives and holds the number one position worldwide for healthcare captives," with healthcare the primary class of business (CIMA). A captive lets a system insure its own malpractice and other risks. The premiums, and the investment income earned on the reserves while claims are pending, stay inside the system instead of going to an outside insurer. The Cayman insurance managers, auditors and actuaries who run these companies are paid for it. The Fiat Lux post walks through how one public institution's captive works.

6. Taxable affiliates

A nonprofit system can own for-profit companies and invest in for-profit partnerships. Their profits are taxed, but they sit inside a structure whose center is exempt. Schedule R counts them:

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Filing entity Related taxable corporations Related partnerships Related tax-exempt organizations
UPMC (parent) 85 14 58
Ascension Health Alliance 61 72 248
CommonSpirit Health 47 90 195
Trinity Health 42 48 220
Providence St. Joseph Health 41 38 102
Cleveland Clinic Foundation 36 15 8
Mayo Clinic 31 2 23
Kaiser Foundation Hospitals 15 38 54
Sutter Health 7 43 19

UPMC's related entities include a string of insurance companies, UPMC Health Plan among them. Ascension's include a holding company for ambulatory surgery center investments and several investment funds. When a related partnership has outside partners, they share in profits earned on a nonprofit system's patients and referrals, and the return does not say who those partners are.

7. Insiders

Schedule L is where a return must disclose money moving to its own officers, directors and key employees, their families and businesses, and its largest donors. Disclosure is the rule working as designed, and none of these entries alleges wrongdoing. They do show who is close enough to the institution to do business with it.

  • Mass General Brigham reported $37.0 million paid for construction services to a business tied to one director, $8.4 million in lease payments and $2.0 million for marketing with a business tied to another director, and $0.9 million for products and services with a third.
  • New York-Presbyterian reported $12.9 million in lease payments for property in which trustees have an interest, and $10.1 million in legal fees to a law firm in which trustees have an interest.
  • Trinity Health reported $20.1 million and $36.8 million in goods and services provided to it by substantial contributors, meaning large donors.
  • National Jewish Health reported five loans to officers and key employees, described as purchase loans and split dollar loans, a common way to fund executive life insurance. The amounts listed were $1.17 million, $0.76 million, $0.74 million, $0.61 million and $0.48 million, about $3.75 million in all.
  • Parkview Medical Center in Pueblo reported a $1.6 million professional services agreement with a director.
  • Cleveland Clinic reported loans to three executive vice presidents of $112,067, $51,200 and $21,047.
  • Family employment is the most common entry. Mayo Clinic listed 13 relatives of trustees, officers and key employees on its payroll, together paid $3.96 million, with the largest single amount $0.91 million. Cleveland Clinic listed 13 entries totaling $1.60 million, and Intermountain listed one trustee's family member paid $1.34 million in wages.

8. Donors

The Treasury puts the deduction for gifts to health institutions at $10.66 billion in fiscal 2025, the largest single subsidy priced in either post (same Treasury source). For some of these organizations, gifts are nearly the whole business: ALSAC reported $2.70 billion in contributions out of $3.29 billion in revenue, St. Jude $2.04 billion out of $2.21 billion, and Shriners $714 million out of $1.58 billion.

Who gets the most from a deduction? Whoever has the highest rate and gives the most. Starting in 2026, gifts by people in the top 37 percent bracket save tax at no more than 35 percent, itemizers lose the first half percent of their income in gifts, and people who take the standard deduction can deduct up to $1,000 of cash gifts, or $2,000 for a married couple (Kiplinger summary of the 2025 law). A household in the 37 percent bracket still saves $35 on a $100 gift, and a household that does not itemize saves a fraction of that. A gift of stock that has risen in value does even more: the donor generally deducts the full market value and never pays tax on the gain (IRS Publication 526). The same asset that compounded untaxed in the donor's hands can then compound untaxed in the charity's. Donors who give through a donor advised fund take the deduction in the year they fund it, whenever the money actually reaches a hospital (earlier post).

9. Who pays for it

Every party above is paid from three sources: taxpayers, government insurance and privately insured patients. The taxpayer side is the Treasury's $3.59 billion a year for hospital bonds and $10.66 billion for health charity gifts, plus the exemption itself, which KFF valued at about $28.1 billion in 2020 (KFF). The private side is in Colorado's numbers: in 2023 private insurers paid Colorado hospitals 163 percent of the cost of care, and the state's provider fee report calls the difference "hospital profits on privately insured patients, which are funded by employers and consumers" (CHASE annual report, 2025). Every employer with a health plan, and every worker whose raise went into premiums, is on that list.

Who benefits most

Putting a dollar figure on each group, using the best figure available and naming whose figure it is:

Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.

Who benefits Best available figure Whose figure
The institutions themselves, through the exemption About $28.1 billion a year (2020) KFF
Donors, through the health charity deduction $10.66 billion a year Treasury
Bondholders, through tax-free interest $3.59 billion a year Treasury
A single vendor on a single return $636.8 million (Conifer, from CommonSpirit) Form 990 Part VII
A single return's executive group $128.6 million (CommonSpirit) Schedule J
A single return's directly billed money managers $82.7 million (Kaiser), before fees taken inside funds Part IX line 11f
The largest single insider transaction $37.0 million (Mass General Brigham) Schedule L

The ranking says something plain. The biggest winners from the tax construct are the institutions' own balance sheets and the people with the highest tax rates: donors who deduct their gifts and investors who hold the bonds. The biggest single private payments go to taxable vendors, increasingly ones owned by private equity. The most concentrated gains, per person, go to the executives whose bonuses track the margin and to the fund managers whose share of profits is taxed at capital gains rates. The people who pay are the taxpayer, the privately insured patient and that patient's employer.

What the filings do not show

  • Fees charged inside investment funds, and the names of individual fund holdings, are not on the 990.
  • Part VII Section B lists only the five largest contractors per return, so the rest of each vendor list is a count, not a set of names.
  • A filing entity is not a whole system. Kaiser's health plan, the University of Colorado Hospital Authority and several hospital companies file separately or not at all.
  • Schedule L entries are disclosures made under each organization's conflict of interest process. A listed transaction is not evidence that the price was unfair.

Related reading

The pattern under all of it, that the best positions go to whoever owns the compounding asset or holds the highest tax bracket, is the subject of The W-2 Trap.

Fact-check notes and sources

This post is informational, not legal, tax or financial advice. All figures are reproduced from public filings and public records. Organizations and companies are discussed from the public record as nominative fair use, with no affiliation implied and nothing endorsed by any of them. Schedule L disclosures are reported as filed and do not imply wrongdoing.

← Back to Blog

Accessibility Options

Text Size
High Contrast
Reduce Motion
Reading Guide
Link Highlighting
Accessibility Statement

J.A. Watte is committed to ensuring digital accessibility for people with disabilities. This site conforms to WCAG 2.1 and 2.2 Level AA guidelines.

Measures Taken

  • Semantic HTML with proper heading hierarchy
  • ARIA labels and roles for interactive components
  • Color contrast ratios meeting WCAG AA (4.5:1)
  • Full keyboard navigation support
  • Skip navigation link
  • Visible focus indicators (3:1 contrast)
  • 44px minimum touch/click targets
  • Dark/light theme with system preference detection
  • Responsive design for all devices
  • Reduced motion support (CSS + toggle)
  • Text size customization (14px–20px)
  • Print stylesheet

Feedback

Contact: jwatte.com/contact

Full Accessibility Statement • Privacy Policy

Last updated: April 2026