Start with a simple question. Of every $100 an investment portfolio gains, how much does its owner keep? A person in the 32 percent bracket trading in a regular brokerage account keeps about $68 if the gain came within a year, and about $85 at the 15 percent long-term rate if it took longer. A private foundation keeps $98.61, because it pays a 1.39 percent excise tax. A taxable company keeps $79 after the 21 percent federal corporate rate. A nonprofit hospital system, or a public charity like a children's hospital fundraiser, keeps all $100. (I laid that comparison out side by side on the after-tax board at Apprised, which is my own project.)
That last line is the subject of this post. Large nonprofit hospital systems and medical charities now hold portfolios that look like a pension fund's: public stocks, private equity, hedge funds, real estate and offshore fund vehicles. The gains come in untaxed. At the same time these institutions collect Medicare and Medicaid payments, federal research grants, state supplemental payments, a federal subsidy on their borrowing and a deduction for the people who donate to them, and they pay their top executives like corporate chiefs. None of that is illegal and much of it is the design. But it is worth seeing in one place, from the filings themselves.
Everything below comes from the newest Form 990 returns of 26 organizations the IRS has released, for fiscal years ending between December 2024 and December 2025, read directly from the IRS e-file data. I added the big Colorado systems, the state's own reports on them, and the federal sources that put a price on each subsidy. Where a figure is an estimate, I say whose estimate it is. A companion post, Who Gets Paid When a Nonprofit Hospital Pays No Tax, follows the money out the door to the vendors, managers, bondholders and executives who receive it.
How to read these numbers
A Form 990 covers one legal entity, not always a whole health system. Some systems file one large return for their biggest hospital company, some file through a parent that mostly holds investments and debt, and some file group returns. So a system's parent can show billions in assets and little revenue, while its hospitals file separately. I name the filing entity each time and never add entities together, because several of them hold interests in one another. A return from the same year that has been amended replaces the original; two in this set are amended returns.
The 990 also does not list individual stocks. It reports investments by category: publicly traded securities on Part X line 11, "other securities" on line 12 with a breakdown on Schedule D, and an endowment roll forward on Schedule D Part V. Related entities, including offshore ones, are on Schedule R. Pay is on Schedule J, tax-exempt bonds on Schedule K, and the hospital community benefit and government payment lines on Schedule H.
What they hold
Here are the largest filers in the set by total assets, with how much sits in securities and what came in from investing during the year.
Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.
| Filing entity (fiscal year end) | Total assets | Publicly traded securities | Other securities (alternatives, pooled funds) | Investment income plus realized gains | Revenue less expenses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Kaiser Foundation Hospitals (Dec 2024) | $87.4B | $16.2B | $31.6B | $3.74B | $4.42B |
| Howard Hughes Medical Institute (Aug 2025) | $29.5B | $5.4B | $21.9B | $1.96B | $0.83B |
| Mayo Clinic (Dec 2024) | $26.7B | $0.8B | $19.9B | $1.17B | $1.62B |
| Ascension Health Alliance (Jun 2025) | $22.2B | n/a | $0.2B | $1.21B | $1.19B |
| Trinity Health Corporation (Jun 2025) | $17.3B | $6.1B | $2.2B | $0.59B | $0.17B |
| Northwestern Memorial HealthCare (Aug 2025) | $16.8B | $3.9B | $7.1B | $0.90B | $0.83B |
| Shriners Hospitals for Children (Dec 2025) | $13.3B | $7.0B | $3.2B | $0.66B | $0.39B |
| ALSAC, the St. Jude fundraising charity (Jun 2025) | $10.9B | n/a | $10.0B | $0.53B | $0.50B |
| Sutter Health (Dec 2024) | $9.6B | $7.2B | $1.4B | $0.53B | $0.14B |
Read the last two columns together. At Trinity, investment income and realized gains of $594 million were more than three times the entity's $175 million surplus for the year. At the Sutter Health filing entity, $528 million in investment income and gains sat beside a $141 million surplus. At Kaiser's hospital company the investment line was $3.74 billion against a $4.42 billion surplus, and Northwestern's $900 million in investment income and gains was larger than its $827 million surplus. Those investment figures do not even include unrealized gains, which the 990 reports further down, in Part XI: another $1.21 billion at Howard Hughes, $680 million at Shriners, $610 million at Mayo and $920 million at New York-Presbyterian.
Schedule D shows what "other securities" means at the institutions that itemize it:
- Kaiser Foundation Hospitals: private equity funds $22.16 billion, real asset funds $5.22 billion, absolute return funds $4.19 billion.
- Howard Hughes Medical Institute: private equity $8.35 billion, public equity $6.74 billion, "independent return" (hedge fund style) $5.20 billion, real assets $1.63 billion.
- ALSAC: global equity $3.92 billion, marketable alternatives $2.49 billion, private equity $2.35 billion, fixed income $0.93 billion, real assets $0.22 billion.
- Cleveland Clinic Foundation: hedge funds $1.79 billion and private equity $1.81 billion, beside $3.35 billion of publicly traded securities and an endowment that Schedule D shows earning $419.7 million in the year.
- Shriners Hospitals for Children: private alternative investments $2.80 billion and real estate and mineral interests $353 million, beside $6.96 billion in public securities. Its endowment earned $1.40 billion in 2025.
- Mayo Clinic: $16.91 billion in its pooled investment fund and $2.97 billion listed as its qualified pension plan.
- Trinity Health: $1.55 billion in equity method investments, $444 million in commingled funds and $222 million in hedge funds.
Schedule R adds the offshore layer. Howard Hughes lists 42 foreign related entities, 21 of them Cayman Islands investment vehicles. The Sutter Health return lists six Cayman investment entities, including a multi-strategy fund run by AQR. Intermountain's parent and its Colorado subsidiary, the former SCL Health system, both list Cayman buyout partnerships investing in Korea and Australia. Cleveland Clinic lists a Jersey lease holding company, a London hospital company and a Cayman insurer. Most of the big systems also own a Cayman or Bermuda captive insurance company, which the companion post covers.
There is a tax reason offshore funds appear on these schedules. When a tax-exempt investor earns income from a fund that borrows, the debt-financed part of that income can be taxed as unrelated business income under section 514 of the tax code. Routing the investment through a foreign corporation, known as a blocker, turns that income into a dividend, which is not taxed as unrelated business income. The IRS has upheld that treatment in private letter rulings, and pension funds and endowments use the same structure (practitioner summary, The Tax Adviser; 26 U.S.C. 514). The returns do not say why each entity exists, so I will not guess at any one of them. The pattern is what the filings show.
The tax gap on the same dollar
Here is the comparison the opening question was pointing at, using the federal rates that apply in 2026.
- A taxable company pays 21 percent federal income tax on investment gains, under section 11 of the tax code, plus state tax.
- A high-income individual pays up to 37 percent on short-term gains and 20 percent on long-term gains, plus the 3.8 percent net investment income tax.
- A private foundation pays a flat 1.39 percent excise tax on net investment income and must pay out about 5 percent of its assets a year (background).
- A large private university now pays up to 8 percent on endowment income under the 2025 tax law.
- A nonprofit hospital or public charity pays nothing on ordinary investment income and gains. The exceptions are unrelated business income, which these returns report as small. Mayo Clinic, with the largest figure in the set, reported $576 million in gross unrelated business income and $54.4 million net.
No payout rule applies to hospitals or to public charities like ALSAC, and the 2025 endowment tax that now reaches the richest universities does not reach hospital systems at all. So a hospital system's reserve compounds at the same market return a corporation or a family office would earn, with no tax taken out along the way. Few employers of any size could match that. The largest taxable hospital company, HCA Healthcare, reported $2.05 billion in income tax expense for its most recent year (earlier post). Its nonprofit competitors report none, and their reserves keep the difference.
The pay
Schedule J lists every officer, director and key employee paid more than $150,000, split into base salary, bonus, other pay, deferred compensation and nontaxable benefits, including pay from related organizations. I report people by title only. The totals below are the highest paid person on each return.
Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.
| Filing entity | Highest paid (title as filed) | Total | Base | Bonus or incentive | People on Schedule J over $1M in reportable pay |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Advocate Health Care Network | President (paid severance in 2024) | $30.9M | $1.8M | $14.4M | 16 |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital | President and CEO | $26.3M | $2.4M | $5.3M | 31 |
| CommonSpirit Health | Chief executive officer | $14.2M | $2.9M | $10.9M | 30 |
| Ascension Health Alliance | CEO | $14.1M | $2.0M | $10.9M | 9 |
| Kaiser Foundation Hospitals | Chairman and CEO | $13.0M | $2.2M | $9.3M | 41 |
| Providence St. Joseph Health | President and CEO | $12.3M | $2.9M | $7.3M | 8 |
| Sutter Health | President and CEO | $11.9M | $2.6M | $8.7M | 22 |
| Cleveland Clinic Foundation | President and CEO | $9.7M | $7.0M | none | 20 |
| Intermountain Health Care | President and CEO | $9.7M | $2.1M | $3.3M | 13 |
| Mass General Brigham | President and CEO | $9.2M | $2.8M | $4.2M | 15 |
| Trinity Health | President and CEO | $7.3M | $2.8M | $3.4M | 13 |
| Mayo Clinic | President and CEO | $4.9M | $3.9M | none | 23 |
| Howard Hughes Medical Institute | Chief investment officer | $2.0M | $1.1M | $0.8M | 5 |
Three things stand out. First, at most of the big systems the bonus is larger than the salary, often three to five times larger. That is the pay design of a public company, tied to targets, and it sits on top of the tax exemption. Second, these are not one or two people. Kaiser's hospital company reported 41 people on Schedule J with more than $1 million in reportable pay, New York-Presbyterian 31, CommonSpirit 30 and Mayo 23, and Kaiser reported 44,711 employees paid more than $100,000. Third, look who tops the Howard Hughes list: its chief investment officer, paid more than the institute's president. The person who runs the portfolio is the best paid person at one of the country's largest medical charities.
The Advocate figure needs its context, which the return supplies. Schedule J Part III shows that total includes a severance payment of about $8.1 million to that president, plus about $0.8 million in contributions to a supplemental executive retirement plan. New York-Presbyterian's chief executive total includes $15.7 million reported as "other compensation", the Schedule J column that holds items such as retirement plan payouts and vested deferred pay, and its Part III lists several severance payments to former officers, the largest $2 million.
Congress has noticed. Since 2018, section 4960 of the tax code has charged tax-exempt employers a 21 percent excise tax on pay above $1 million, but only for their five highest paid employees. The 2025 tax law removed the five-person cap for tax years beginning after December 31, 2025, so starting in 2026 the tax applies to every employee paid more than $1 million (EY summary of the final law). On these returns that means dozens of people per system. The tax falls on the employer, which means it is paid out of the same tax-free revenue.
Colorado's big systems
Colorado is a useful test case because the state measures its hospitals in ways most states do not. Its Department of Health Care Policy and Financing publishes annual reports on hospital finances and community benefit, and since a 2023 law its Department of Revenue estimates what each nonprofit hospital's tax exemption is worth.
The Colorado filers in this set, from their newest returns:
Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.
| Filing entity | Revenue | Revenue less expenses | Highest paid (title) | Charity care, % of expenses | Total community benefit, % of expenses |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Poudre Valley Health Care, Inc. (UCHealth, Jun 2025, amended) | $1.03B | $221.4M | CEO, $1.7M ($0.9M of it bonus) | 1.23% | 19.47% |
| Children's Hospital Colorado (Dec 2024) | $2.01B | $46.2M | CEO, $4.3M | 0.15% | 22.39% |
| Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado, CommonSpirit's Colorado hospitals (Jun 2025, amended) | $3.44B | minus $194.6M | System executive, $5.5M ($3.7M bonus) | 4.24% | 17.87% |
| PorterCare Adventist Health System, AdventHealth (Dec 2024) | $1.80B | $28.0M | Departing chair, $4.9M | 2.14% | 8.58% |
| Sisters of Charity of Leavenworth Health System, now Intermountain (Dec 2024) | $0.99B | $123.1M | Former officer, $3.8M | 0.10% | 0.54% |
| National Jewish Health (Jun 2025) | $0.38B | minus $7.8M | President and CEO, $3.9M ($1.5M deferred) | 0.03% | 12.20% |
| Parkview Medical Center, Pueblo (Jun 2025) | $0.55B | $0.5M | Physician, $3.6M | 1.08% | 19.10% |
| Valley View Hospital, Glenwood Springs (Dec 2024) | $0.37B | $34.3M | Cardiac surgeon, $1.4M | 3.43% | 13.63% |
The UCHealth entity is the striking one. Poudre Valley Health Care, Inc. reported about $1.03 billion in revenue but $11.66 billion in total assets, including $2.61 billion in publicly traded securities, so its return carries far more balance sheet than its own hospitals would need. UCHealth's flagship hospital on the Anschutz campus belongs to the University of Colorado Hospital Authority, which appears as the bond issuer on this return's Schedule K and is not among the returns here. The state's own report explains where the money showed up: between 2022 and 2023, Colorado hospitals' total net income rose by $1.2 billion, and UCHealth's University Hospital and Poudre Valley Hospital alone accounted for $612.7 million and $430.8 million of it. Excluding those two, the rest of the state's hospitals gained only $117.7 million. The report says plainly that "net income levels are highly influenced by the investment markets as most of a hospital's non-operating income comes from gains on investments" (HCPF Hospital Financial Transparency Report, 2025). The same report found UCHealth's total margin for the first half of 2024 above 17 percent.
Reserves, measured in days of operating cash on hand, tell the same story. For 2023 the state lists Intermountain (as the former SCL Health) at 348 days, UCHealth at 308, Children's Hospital Colorado at 291, AdventHealth at 201 and CommonSpirit at 164, against a statewide median of 164 days. Denver Health, the safety net hospital for the city, had 85 days, and National Jewish Health 62.
Then the state put a price on the exemption. The Colorado Department of Revenue estimated federal and state income tax and property tax forgone by nonprofit hospitals at $571.7 million for fiscal 2023, by system: UCHealth $274.1 million, CommonSpirit $95.9 million, independent hospitals $68.8 million, AdventHealth $47.9 million, Intermountain $44.5 million, Children's Hospital Colorado $27.1 million and Banner $13.3 million (HCPF Hospital Community Benefit Accountability Report, 2026). That estimate leaves out the bond subsidy and donor deductions, and it uses fiscal 2022 net income, a year when investment markets fell, so it is low for a good market year. Measured against it, the state found almost every system spent more on community benefit than the exemption was worth, with AdventHealth the exception, and that Montrose Memorial and Valley View spent less than their estimated exemption on community benefit when Medicaid shortfall is excluded. Much of the gap at the top is teaching: of UCHealth's $826.1 million in reported community benefit, $713.6 million fell in the category for provider recruitment, education, research and training.
Layer by layer: the public money underneath
The tax exemption is only the first subsidy. Here is the full stack, with the best available price on each.
1. The tax exemption itself
KFF estimated that nonprofit hospitals' tax exemption was worth about $28.1 billion in 2020: $14.4 billion in federal taxes, mostly income tax, and $13.7 billion in state and local taxes, mostly property tax. That exceeded the roughly $16 billion they spent on charity care that year (KFF). The American Hospital Association, using different methods, puts the federal figure at $13.2 billion for 2022 and argues that hospitals returned $149 billion in community benefit as reported on Schedule H (AHA). The Lown Institute, which does not count the Medicaid shortfall as community benefit, found 54 percent of hospitals spent less on community investment than their tax breaks were worth in its 2025 report (Lown Institute). Both sides agree on the size of the exemption. They disagree on what counts as paying it back.
2. Cheaper borrowing, paid for by federal taxpayers
Hospitals borrow through state and local conduit authorities, and the interest their bondholders receive is tax-free. The Treasury prices that exclusion for hospital construction bonds at $3.59 billion in fiscal 2025 and $41.0 billion over 2025 through 2034 (Treasury tax expenditures, fiscal 2026). Hospitals also get a carve out other charities do not: when Congress capped the tax-exempt bonds any one charity could have outstanding at $150 million, qualified hospital bonds were excluded from the cap (IRS training text on section 145).
The balance sheets show the result. On their newest returns, Kaiser's hospital company carried $6.08 billion in tax-exempt bond liabilities, Ascension $5.47 billion, Intermountain's parent $4.82 billion, Trinity $4.66 billion, UPMC's parent $4.59 billion, CommonSpirit's parent $4.12 billion, Cleveland Clinic $3.57 billion and Mass General Brigham $3.15 billion, every one of them beside a large investment portfolio. The arbitrage rules in section 148 of the tax code limit what borrowed bond money itself may earn while it waits to be spent. They do not stop an institution from borrowing at tax-exempt rates while its own reserve stays invested in stocks and private equity.
3. Donors' deductions
Gifts to hospitals and medical charities are deductible, which is a federal cost too. The Treasury puts the deduction for charitable contributions to health institutions at $10.66 billion in fiscal 2025 and $152.8 billion over 2025 through 2034 (same Treasury source). Shriners, ALSAC and St. Jude are built on those gifts.
4. Medicare and Medicaid, through CMS
Government insurance is the largest public money of all. Nationally, hospital care cost $1.6 trillion in 2024, the biggest single category of health spending, and Medicare and Medicaid together spent about $2 trillion on all care that year (CMS national health expenditure highlights). Schedule H shows how much flowed to each filer. These are the Medicaid payments and Medicare revenue the hospitals themselves reported:
Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.
| Filing entity | Medicaid payments received | Medicaid cost of that care | Medicare revenue (Schedule H Part III) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kaiser Foundation Hospitals | $2.30B | $3.05B | $0.46B |
| New York-Presbyterian Hospital | $1.44B | $2.36B | $1.28B |
| Cleveland Clinic Foundation | $0.68B | $1.10B | $0.83B |
| Children's Hospital Colorado | $0.53B | $0.86B | $0.004B |
| Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado | $0.44B | $0.90B | $0.37B |
| PorterCare Adventist (AdventHealth) | $0.18B | $0.30B | $0.20B |
| Poudre Valley Health Care (UCHealth) | $0.08B | $0.13B | $0.16B |
| Parkview Medical Center | $0.14B | $0.14B | $0.07B |
Hospitals are right that Medicaid usually pays less than cost, and that shortfall is the largest piece of the community benefit they report. Kaiser's hospitals, for example, put their Medicaid shortfall at $752.7 million. But the payments are still public money, and they are the base the rest of the business is built on. Kaiser's Medicare line is small because Kaiser is an integrated insurer and provider, and its health plan, Kaiser Foundation Health Plan, files its own return.
5. Federal research grants, through HHS
The National Institutes of Health is part of the Department of Health and Human Services. Its project database shows fiscal 2025 awards of $702.7 million to Massachusetts General Hospital, $465.9 million to Brigham and Women's (both Mass General Brigham hospitals), $343.2 million to Mayo Clinic in Rochester, $144.6 million to St. Jude, $133.4 million to Cleveland Clinic's Lerner College of Medicine, $111.1 million to Kaiser Foundation Research Institute and $34.0 million to National Jewish Health (NIH RePORTER). On the 990s themselves, the government grants line shows $389.1 million at Mayo Clinic, $298.3 million at Kaiser's hospitals, $197.3 million at Cleveland Clinic and $143.7 million at St. Jude.
6. State supplemental payments: Colorado's provider fee
Colorado charges its hospitals a fee, uses it to draw down federal Medicaid matching money, and pays the combined amount back to the hospitals as supplemental payments. In federal fiscal 2023 to 2024, hospitals paid $1.26 billion in fees and received $1.75 billion in supplemental payments, a net gain of $494.5 million (CHASE annual report, 2025). The draft report for 2024 to 2025 shows $1.42 billion in fees and $1.90 billion in payments, a net of $483.4 million, and notes the fee money also funds coverage for more than 438,000 Coloradans.
7. Pandemic relief
Colorado's transparency report estimates about $1.2 billion in federal COVID-19 stimulus went to Colorado hospital organizations, and notes that stimulus helped lift hospital cash reserves in 2020 and 2021.
8. Discounted drugs
The 340B program lets qualifying hospitals buy outpatient drugs at deep discounts and bill insurers at full price. It is large enough to need its own post.
9. The privately insured and their employers
The subsidy nobody votes on is the price paid by private insurance. Colorado's provider fee report tracks it: in 2023, private insurers paid Colorado hospitals 163 percent of the cost of care, while Medicaid paid 79 percent. In the draft 2024 data, private payments grew 10.7 percent against 9.1 percent cost growth, and the report calls the difference "hospital profits on privately insured patients, which are funded by employers and consumers." That is the money every employer with a health plan is sending in.
Prices that outrun inflation
All of that support has not made hospital care cheaper. The consumer price index for hospital services rose 51.5 percent from December 2015 to December 2025, while prices overall rose 37.0 percent. From December 2019 the gap is narrower, 29.3 percent against 26.1 percent, and in the twelve months to September 2026 it widened again, 5.6 percent against 3.7 percent (BLS CPI series CUUR0000SEMD01 and CUUR0000SA0). Colorado's draft provider fee report adds a cost side: hospital costs rose 47.4 percent from 2019 to 2024, about half of it general inflation, while payments rose 36.8 percent.
So the honest picture is this. Hospitals face real cost growth, especially in labor, and public payers often pay below cost. But the system leaders in these filings meet that with a reserve that compounds tax-free, a borrowing subsidy, a donor deduction, government payment streams, and prices to private payers that run well above cost, while their bonus pools grow with the margin.
Pensions and the others in the same pool
The same structure runs through retirement money. Pension trusts, 401(k) plans and IRAs are tax-exempt while the money stays inside, which is why the after-tax board above shows them keeping more than a taxable account. Hospital systems sit on both sides of that. Kaiser's hospital company reported $1.25 billion in pension plan accruals and contributions for 2024, and Mayo Clinic lists a $2.97 billion line labeled "qualified pension plan" among its other securities. At Kaiser, as an earlier post found from its audited statements, the pension is about 61 percent in alternative investments and is run by the same in-house investment office as the operating reserves.
Three features stretch the advantage further:
- Church plans. A pension plan run by a church-affiliated hospital system can be a "church plan" exempt from most of ERISA, including its funding rules, disclosure requirements and the federal insurance the PBGC provides. The Supreme Court confirmed that exemption unanimously in 2017 in Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton, a case brought against Advocate and Dignity Health, which merged with Catholic Health Initiatives in 2019 to form CommonSpirit (Cornell LII; GAO-23-105080). In a later settlement of the class action over its plan, Dignity agreed to put $50 million into the plan for 2020 and at least $50 million more (PlanAdviser). GAO notes that because church plans generally do not file the federal reports other plans file, data on them is limited.
- Executive retirement plans. Of the 24 returns here with Schedule J entries, 22 checked the box for a supplemental nonqualified retirement plan, a pension on top of the pension for executives. Deferred pay shows up in the numbers too: Intermountain's chief executive had $4.2 million in deferred compensation in one year, Kaiser's Schedule J totaled $17.5 million in deferred pay across 76 people, and National Jewish Health's chief executive $1.5 million.
- The blocker. As above, tax-exempt pension funds and endowments use offshore corporations to keep income from funds that borrow from being taxed. The hospital portfolios and the pension funds are customers of the same funds.
None of this makes a pension or a hospital reserve a bad thing. A hospital without reserves is one bad year from closing, and the Colorado report shows rural hospitals with as little as 25 days of cash. The issue is scale and direction: the biggest systems hold years of reserves, compound them untaxed, and draw public money on top.
What the filings do not show
To be fair to the institutions and to the reader:
- The 990 does not show individual stock holdings, and most of these organizations do not file the SEC holdings reports that would.
- A filing entity is not the whole system. Several systems' hospitals file separately, and the Colorado state reports use consolidated figures that will not match any single 990.
- Community benefit is a contested measure. Teaching, research and the Medicaid shortfall are real costs, and whether they "count" is the policy argument, not a settled fact.
- The tax exemption estimates differ by method. KFF, the AHA, the Lown Institute and the Colorado Department of Revenue each measure something slightly different, and I have given each one's number with its name on it.
Related reading
- Who Gets Paid When a Nonprofit Hospital Pays No Tax: the follow up, on vendors, managers, bondholders, executives and affiliates.
- The Margin Is Thin, the Portfolio Is Not: how investment returns decide a hospital's year, with the Schedule H charity care numbers for six more systems.
- The Hundred-Billion-Dollar Nonprofit Whose Profit Rides on the Market: Kaiser Permanente in depth.
- The 340B Drug Pricing Program: the drug discount subsidy.
- The Tax Reform Act of 1969 and the endowment tax: why foundations pay 1.39 percent and hospitals pay nothing.
- Fiat Lux, a university's captive insurer: how an institution keeps its own insurance float.
If the thread running through this post, that the biggest advantages go to whoever owns the compounding asset rather than whoever does the work, is the part that interests you, it is the subject of The W-2 Trap.
Fact-check notes and sources
- All Form 990 figures (total assets, Part X securities, Part VIII investment income and gains, Part XI unrealized gains, Part IX pension contributions, Schedule D investment categories and endowment figures, Schedule J pay, Schedule K bonds, Schedule H Medicaid and Medicare lines and community benefit, Schedule R related entities): read from each organization's newest return in the IRS Form 990 e-file data release (IRS Form 990 series downloads). Each organization's filings are also viewable at ProPublica's Nonprofit Explorer: Kaiser Foundation Hospitals, Howard Hughes Medical Institute, Mayo Clinic, Ascension Health Alliance, New York-Presbyterian Hospital, Cleveland Clinic Foundation, Trinity Health, Northwestern Memorial HealthCare, Shriners Hospitals for Children, St. Jude, ALSAC, CommonSpirit Health, Mass General Brigham, UPMC, Sutter Health, Intermountain Health Care, Providence St. Joseph Health, Advocate Health Care Network, Poudre Valley Health Care (UCHealth), Children's Hospital Colorado, Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado, PorterCare Adventist Health System, SCL Health System, National Jewish Health, Parkview Medical Center and Valley View Hospital.
- Fiscal years: December 2024 for Kaiser, Mayo, Cleveland Clinic, New York-Presbyterian, Sutter, Intermountain, Providence St. Joseph, Advocate, Children's Hospital Colorado, PorterCare Adventist, SCL Health and Valley View; June 2025 for Ascension, Trinity, CommonSpirit, UPMC, St. Jude, ALSAC, Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado, Poudre Valley, National Jewish and Parkview; August 2025 for Howard Hughes and Northwestern; September 2025 for Mass General Brigham; December 2025 for Shriners. The Poudre Valley and Catholic Health Initiatives Colorado returns are amended returns.
- "People over $1M" counts Schedule J rows whose reportable pay (base, bonus and other, excluding deferred and nontaxable benefits) exceeds $1 million. "Employees over $100,000" is Part VII Section A line 2 of the return.
- Advocate severance and supplemental retirement contributions, and New York-Presbyterian severance payments: Schedule J Part III of each return.
- Section 4960 and the 2025 change: EY Tax News, final reconciliation legislation and tax-exempt entities.
- Blocker corporations and debt-financed income: The Tax Adviser; 26 U.S.C. 514. IRS country code CJ on Schedule R is the Cayman Islands.
- Colorado figures (net income change, investment market statement, UCHealth 2024 margin, days cash on hand, $1.2 billion stimulus): HCPF Hospital Financial Transparency Report, 2025. Tax exemption estimates by system and community benefit categories: HCPF Hospital Community Benefit Accountability Report, 2026, Table 11 and Appendix G. Provider fee and payer ratios: CHASE annual report, 2025 and the draft 2026 report, which is marked draft.
- Tax exemption value: KFF, AHA, Lown Institute.
- Hospital bond and health charity deduction tax expenditures: Treasury, Tax Expenditures FY2026, Table 1, lines 131 and 134. Section 145 cap: IRS training text.
- National spending: CMS NHE highlights. NIH awards: NIH RePORTER, fiscal year 2025, by organization name.
- Prices: BLS consumer price index, U.S. city average, not seasonally adjusted, hospital services (CUUR0000SEMD01) and all items (CUUR0000SA0), via the BLS data tools.
- Church plans: Advocate Health Care Network v. Stapleton, Cornell LII; GAO-23-105080; Dignity settlement terms per PlanAdviser. CommonSpirit's 2019 formation: CommonSpirit.
This post is informational, not legal, tax or financial advice. All figures are reproduced from public filings and public records. Organizations are discussed from the public record as nominative fair use, with no affiliation implied and nothing endorsed by any of them.