Part 1 of this series added up the public money under the largest nonprofit hospital systems: the tax exemption, the bond subsidy, the donor deduction, Medicare and Medicaid, research grants and state payments, plus portfolios that compound without tax. Part 2 followed the money to vendors, executives, money managers, bondholders and insiders. Part 2 also noted that nearly every big system owns an insurance company, most of them in the Cayman Islands.
This part opens those insurers up: how big they are, how money moves between a hospital and its own insurer, and how the tax law treats each step. Then it closes the loop on the whole cycle. The last section turns to the reader: which pieces of the same playbook a family with well under $50 million can actually use, since a family office does not make sense at that size.
What a captive is
A captive is an insurance company owned by the organization it insures. A hospital system sets one up to cover its own malpractice and general liability claims instead of buying that coverage from a commercial insurer. The hospital pays premiums to its captive. The captive holds reserves for claims that may take years to settle, invests those reserves, and buys reinsurance from commercial carriers for the largest losses. The underwriting profit and the investment income stay inside the system instead of going to an outside insurer.
That is a real risk management tool, and malpractice risk is real: an actuarial review of about 40,000 closed hospital claims selected severity trends of 5.0 percent a year with no cap and 4.5 percent for claims limited to $5 million (Milliman, 2025). The question here is not whether hospitals should insure themselves. It is where the reserves sit, what they earn, and who pays tax on it.
What the 990s show
Schedule R of each Form 990 lists related organizations. For a related corporation it reports the entity's income, year-end assets and the share the hospital owns. For a disregarded entity, a company the tax law treats as part of its owner, it reports the entity's income and assets directly. Here are the larger insurers with reported figures on the newest returns, for tax year 2024 (fiscal years ending from December 2024 to August 2025), read from the IRS e-file data. For a corporation the figures are the hospital's share, which equals the whole when it owns 100 percent:
Scroll to compare columns and rows when the table extends beyond the box.
| System (filing entity) | Captive, as filed | Domicile | Income | Year-end assets | How it is filed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| CommonSpirit Health | First Initiatives Insurance Ltd | Cayman Islands | $525.0M | $1.89B | Disregarded entity |
| Northwestern Memorial HealthCare | Northwestern Medicine Insurance Co LLC | District of Columbia | $253.6M | $1.43B | Disregarded entity |
| Trinity Health | Trinity Assurance Ltd | Cayman Islands | minus $6.6M | $865.3M | Corporation, 100% owned |
| Cleveland Clinic Foundation | CCHS Indemnity Co Ltd | Cayman Islands | $81.7M | $279.4M | Corporation, 100% owned |
| Mayo Clinic | Mayo Insurance Company Ltd | Cayman Islands | $40.4M | $185.7M | Corporation, 100% owned |
| Intermountain Health Care | Mountain West Health Captive | Cayman Islands | $84.1M | $181.5M | Corporation, 100% owned |
| CommonSpirit Health | Strategic and Physicians Insurance Ltd | Cayman Islands | $5.5M | $48.8M | Corporation, 100% owned |
| Children's Hospital Colorado | 5314 Insurance Company LLC | Hawaii | $4.8M | $39.1M | Disregarded entity |
The six Cayman captives with reported figures hold about $3.45 billion in assets (my sum). Others appear without figures: UPMC's parent lists four Cayman insurers, Panther Reinsurance, Forbes Reinsurance, Cathedral (Re) Insurance and Western Maryland Insurance, without amounts; Advocate lists Advocate Insurance SPC in Cayman; Ascension lists Ascension Health Insurance Limited and Sunflower Assurance in Cayman; Kaiser's hospital return lists two Cayman entities, one described as an insurer, with their amounts filed as zero; New York-Presbyterian lists Network Insurance Company in Bermuda with $5.9 million in assets. Smaller domestic entries with figures include Cleveland Clinic's South Carolina risk retention group ($19.2 million in assets), Intermountain's Arizona captive ($5.5 million) and Ascension's Missouri workers' compensation self-insurance trust ($154.7 million).
The filing type matters. When a captive is filed as a disregarded entity, as CommonSpirit's largest and Northwestern's are, the tax law treats its income as the hospital's own income. When it is filed as a separate corporation, as Trinity's, Cleveland Clinic's, Mayo's and Intermountain's are, it is a company of its own, and its domicile, its tax elections and whom it insures decide how it is taxed.
What the audited statements add
The systems' audited financial statements show the reserves behind these companies. They rarely name the captive or its domicile, so the figures below are for each system's self-insurance program as a whole:
- CommonSpirit held $2.09 billion of assets "held for self-insured claims" at June 30, 2026, against $1.75 billion in current and long-term self-insured reserves combined (my sum), and describes "offshore and onshore captive insurance companies" (2026 annual report, Notes 1, 7 and 12).
- Northwestern held $1.35 billion in assets for self-insurance programs at August 31, 2025, up from $928 million a year earlier (audited statements, Note 4).
- Trinity's captive, Trinity Assurance, had total assets of $879.5 million at June 30, 2026, by the consolidating schedule in its FY2026 statements, and places its reinsurance "with 22 commercial third party reinsurers" (Note 7). Trinity's FY2025 statements say a captive it absorbed, Misericordia Assurance, was "domiciled in the Cayman Islands."
- Cleveland Clinic: "Through the captive insurance subsidiaries, the System has set aside investments of $281.4 million" (2025 statements, Note 14).
- UPMC designated $758.6 million for its professional and general liability program, and its management discussion says "approximately $2.7 billion was held by UPMC's regulated health and captive insurance companies" (2025 report, Notes 5 and 11).
- Ascension carries $1.03 billion in professional and general liability reserves, discounted at 5.5 percent, with excess coverage through its captive, AHIL, up to $220 million, "primarily reinsured by commercial carriers" (FY2026 statements, Note 15).
How money moves between a hospital and its insurer
Part V of Schedule R lists transactions with related organizations by type. The codes come from the form itself (Schedule R). The larger insurer-related entries on these returns:
- Trinity Health reported $125.8 million in reimbursement paid to Trinity Assurance for expenses, $81.2 million in reimbursement paid by it, and a $2.0 million gift or capital contribution from it.
- Cleveland Clinic reported $44.8 million in reimbursement paid to CCHS Indemnity and $31.8 million in loans or loan guarantees by CCHS Indemnity.
- Kaiser Foundation Hospitals reported, with Lokahi Assurance, a Hawaii insurer listed as a related tax-exempt organization controlled by Kaiser's health plan: $330.6 million for services performed by Lokahi, $173.7 million in loans to it, $170.8 million received from it as interest, annuities, royalties or rent, and $86.7 million for services performed for it.
- Ascension reported $63.1 million in other transfers of cash or property to its professional and general liability self-insurance trust and $24.4 million in reimbursement paid by it.
Three other channels show money coming back to the hospital:
- Dividends. Mass General Brigham owns 11 percent of CRICO, a Vermont reciprocal risk retention group. Its 2025 statements say: "During 2025, CRICO announced and paid a dividend to member organizations," and MGB recorded "dividend income of $120,595" thousand, about $120.6 million (MGB 2025 statements, Note 16).
- Loans back to affiliates. Vermont's regulator reports that its 111 healthcare captives held $18.0 billion in assets in 2023, including $2.26 billion in "Loans to Affiliates" (Vermont DFR 2023 aggregate report, unaudited).
- Investment earnings in hospital revenue. Trinity, Cleveland Clinic and Advocate (audited statements) report the earnings on captive or self-insurance assets in their own other revenue, and Ascension shows "self-insurance trust fund investment return" as a separate part of income from operations.
UPMC adds one more: its captives insure "other entities not included in the consolidated financial statements," and older policies "have retrospective clauses that permit additional premiums or refunds."
How the tax law treats each step
In Cayman, no direct taxes. "Corporate income, capital gains, payroll, or other direct taxes are not imposed on corporations in the Cayman Islands" (PwC tax summaries). An exempted company can also get a government undertaking that any future tax on profits will not apply to it; a Cayman law firm says these are granted "for a period of twenty years" (Conyers), and the 1999 revision of the statute allowed up to thirty (Tax Concessions Law, s.6). The Cayman Islands Monetary Authority counts 127 captives whose main line is medical malpractice, with $3.67 billion in annual premium and $15.32 billion in assets, as of the third quarter of 2026 (CIMA statistics).
In the United States, the rule was written in 1996. Before then, a congressional committee report explained, "A tax-exempt organization that conducts insurance activities through a foreign corporation is not subject to U.S. tax with respect to such activities." Congress changed that because third-party insurance could be "conducted by the organization through a controlled foreign corporation that is subject to little tax relative to competing U.S. businesses" (H. Rept. 104-586, pp. 136 to 138). The fix, section 512(b)(17), makes a foreign captive's insurance income taxable to its exempt parent as unrelated business income, but with an exception: insurance of the organization itself, of its tax-exempt affiliates, and of its directors, officers and the people who perform services for it, such as physicians, stays outside the tax (26 U.S.C. 512). The committee wanted a safe harbor where at least 80 percent of a covered physician's services are for the hospital. So for a foreign captive taxed as a foreign company, insuring the hospital and its tax-exempt affiliates creates no taxable income for the owner under this rule. Insuring outsiders, including the system's own taxable affiliates, does, and the parent reports it on Form 990-T under a code reserved for exactly this (IRS Form 990-T instructions, code 901301).
Dividends come home untaxed. Dividends are excluded from unrelated business income under section 512(b)(1), so a captive's dividend to its exempt parent is not taxed on the way back. Interest, rent and royalties from a controlled company can be taxed under section 512(b)(13); dividends are not on that list.
Two choices change the tax on the premiums. A foreign insurer's U.S. premiums owe a federal excise tax of 4 cents on the dollar for casualty insurance and 1 cent for reinsurance (26 U.S.C. 4371). A foreign captive can instead elect under section 953(d) to be taxed as a U.S. company, which the IRS says makes it "subject to tax in the United States on its worldwide income" and lifts the excise tax (Rev. Proc. 2003-47). A U.S. non-life insurer is taxed at the regular corporate rate (26 U.S.C. 831) unless an exemption covers it. A captive filed as a disregarded entity, like CommonSpirit's largest and Northwestern's, is treated as part of its owner, so the foreign-company rule above does not apply; its income is the hospital's own. The public record I read does not say which of these captives made which choice.
The exemption has edges. A charity loses exemption if a substantial part of its activity is "commercial-type insurance" (26 U.S.C. 501(m)), and the charitable risk pool exception in 501(n) excludes "risks related to medical malpractice." But the IRS has long held that a trust a hospital creates solely to pay its own malpractice claims is itself exempt (Rev. Rul. 78-41), and it has allowed such a trust to insure a for-profit affiliate in small amounts, while treating those premiums as unrelated business income (PLR 200501017).
Put together, as I read these rules: a commercial insurer pays corporate tax on its underwriting profit and its investment income. A hospital's Cayman captive filed as a corporation that has not elected U.S. treatment pays no Cayman income tax, its coverage of the hospital and its exempt affiliates creates no unrelated business income for the owner, and its dividends come home untaxed; its U.S. premiums carry the excise tax, and coverage of outsiders or taxable affiliates is taxed. A captive that elected U.S. treatment, or a U.S. captive, pays U.S. corporate tax unless an exemption covers it. Which path each captive in the table took is not in the public record I read.
The cycle, closed
Here is the whole loop the three parts describe, step by step, with sources for each figure:
- Public money in. Tax exemption worth about $28.1 billion a year (KFF, 2020), the hospital bond exclusion worth $3.59 billion a year and the health charity deduction worth $10.66 billion (Treasury), plus Medicare, Medicaid, research grants and state supplemental payments (part 1).
- Prices above inflation. Hospital services prices rose 51.5 percent from December 2015 to December 2025, against 37.0 percent for all prices (BLS), and private insurers paid Colorado hospitals 163 percent of cost in 2023 (part 1).
- Reserves pile up. Nonprofit hospitals' unrestricted cash and investments rose "from $446 billion in 2019 to $548 billion in 2022" in a sample of 274 systems (KFF). A study of 2,366 hospitals' Form 990s found securities holdings up 57 percent from 2010 to $296 billion in 2023, "with other securities investments more than doubling" (Health Affairs, July 2026, PubMed abstract); those private and alternative holdings reached $99 billion, 9.3 percent of total assets, and total securities had peaked at $374 billion in 2021 (Fierce Healthcare summary).
- Returns, untaxed, become the cushion. Fitch found that from 2020 to 2023, investment returns "contributed 28 days" to the median hospital's days of cash on hand while the median rose only 4 days (Fierce on Fitch). The median rated system held 212 days of cash in fiscal 2025 by Fitch's count (HFMA) and 188 by Moody's (Becker's).
- Captives hold another layer, described above, taxed fully, lightly or not at all, depending on where they are domiciled, what they elected and whom they insure.
- Everyone buys the same kinds of assets. College endowments held $944.3 billion in fiscal 2025 (NACUBO-Commonfund summary), with 54.1 percent in "alternative and other strategies," 62.2 percent at the largest (allocation tables). The Federal Reserve puts nonprofit organizations' financial assets at $8.74 trillion at the end of 2025, including $1.03 trillion in hedge fund shares and $1.87 trillion held by private foundations (Z.1, table S15.b). Part 1 showed hospital returns listing offshore fund vehicles on Schedule R, and part 2 named some of their managers. These aggregate figures show that hospitals, universities and foundations are buying the same kinds of private and hedge fund assets, all on the tax-exempt side; they do not show which individual funds each one holds.
- And the cycle repeats (my summary): larger reserves earn larger returns, while the bonds, the deduction and the exemption renew every year.
None of the steps is illegal, and each has a defense: reserves protect hospitals from bad years, captives control insurance costs, endowments fund scholarships. My conclusion from drawing the loop: the advantage at every step goes to whoever already holds the compounding asset, and the costs land on taxpayers and on the employers and workers who pay the private prices.
What a family with under $50 million can use
You cannot get a tax exemption or a Cayman insurer. But several of the same mechanics, untaxed compounding, tax-free interest, deductions for giving and owning the asset that grows, are open to individuals, with limits. These are the 2026 figures from IRS sources. This is information, not advice; check your own situation with a professional.
Compound without tax
- Workplace plans. You can defer $24,500 into a 401(k), 403(b) or governmental 457 plan in 2026, plus $8,000 at 50 and older, or $11,250 at ages 60 to 63 (IRS). If your 2025 wages from that employer were over $150,000, catch-up contributions must go in as Roth (Notice 2025-67).
- The after-tax route. Total additions to a plan account, from you and your employer together, can reach $72,000 in 2026, not counting catch-ups (Notice 2025-67). If your plan accepts after-tax contributions and lets you convert them to Roth, the space between your deferrals and that cap can become Roth money (26 U.S.C. 402A; IRS on after-tax rollovers). It depends entirely on the plan document.
- IRAs. $7,500, plus $1,100 at 50 and older. Direct Roth contributions phase out between $153,000 and $168,000 for single filers and $242,000 and $252,000 for joint filers. Above that, a nondeductible contribution converted to Roth works, but every traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRA you hold counts in the tax on the conversion (26 U.S.C. 408(d)(2); Form 8606 instructions).
- Health savings accounts. $4,400 for self-only coverage and $8,750 for family coverage in 2026 (Rev. Proc. 2025-19), plus $1,000 at 55. Contributions are deductible, growth is untaxed and withdrawals for medical costs are tax-free (26 U.S.C. 223). From 2026, bronze and catastrophic marketplace plans count as qualifying plans, and direct primary care memberships up to $150 a month no longer disqualify you (Notice 2026-5). Paying medical bills out of pocket and leaving the account invested turns it into one more untaxed portfolio.
- Self-employed. A one-person 401(k) combines the $24,500 deferral with an employer contribution, up to the $72,000 total; a SEP allows 25 percent of pay up to $72,000 (IRS).
- Children. 529 plans now cover up to $20,000 a year of K-12 costs and more types of expenses, and unused money can roll into the beneficiary's Roth IRA, up to $35,000 over a lifetime, after 15 years (26 U.S.C. 529). The new Trump accounts take up to $5,000 a year, including up to $2,500 from an employer, with a $1,000 Treasury deposit for children born from 2025 through 2028 (IRS provisions page; IRS Trump Accounts).
Be the bondholder
The hospital bond subsidy goes to the people who hold the bonds, and individuals hold about 70 percent of all municipal bonds, 48 percent directly and 21 percent through mutual funds (MSRB market facts). Interest on state and local bonds is excluded from federal income (26 U.S.C. 103), and nonprofit hospital bonds, as qualified 501(c)(3) bonds, are not an alternative minimum tax item (26 U.S.C. 57(a)(5)(C)(ii)). To compare one with a taxable bond, divide the tax-free yield by one minus your tax rate: a 3.5 percent tax-free yield equals about 5.4 percent taxable at a 35 percent rate (my arithmetic). Treasury interest is free of state income tax (31 U.S.C. 3124). The higher your bracket, the more this is worth, which is the CRS point from part 2 seen from the buyer's side.
Hold, harvest and pass it on
- Hold long. A married couple pays 0 percent on long-term gains and qualified dividends up to $98,900 of taxable income in 2026, and 15 percent up to $613,700 (Rev. Proc. 2025-32). The 3.8 percent net investment income tax starts at $250,000 joint and $200,000 single, and those thresholds are not indexed (IRS).
- Harvest losses with care. A loss is disallowed if you buy substantially identical stock within 30 days before or after the sale, and the IRS says that includes buying it in your IRA (26 U.S.C. 1091; Pub. 550). Direct indexing, owning the index's stocks yourself to harvest losses, has become available below the old $1 million minimums, possibly at higher fees (FINRA).
- Step up. Heirs take a basis equal to market value at death, so gains never sold are never taxed (26 U.S.C. 1014). The 2026 estate and gift exemption is $15 million per person and the annual gift exclusion is $19,000 (Rev. Proc. 2025-32).
Give like an institution
- Give appreciated stock held over a year: you generally deduct its full value and never pay tax on the gain (Pub. 526).
- After 70½, give from your IRA. Qualified charitable distributions of up to $111,000 in 2026 go straight to charity, untaxed, and count toward required distributions, whether or not you itemize (Notice 2025-67; IRS). They cannot go to a donor-advised fund (26 U.S.C. 408(d)(8)).
- Charitable remainder trusts let you sell an appreciated asset inside the trust without immediate tax, take an income stream for life or up to 20 years, and leave at least 10 percent to charity (IRS).
- Know the 2026 changes. Itemizers lose the first 0.5 percent of income in gifts; top-bracket donors save at most about 35 cents per dollar (my reading of the 2/37 reduction in 26 U.S.C. 68); non-itemizers can deduct up to $1,000, or $2,000 joint, of cash gifts, but not gifts to donor-advised funds (26 U.S.C. 170; IRS). A private foundation still pays 1.39 percent on investment income (26 U.S.C. 4940) and must pay out about 5 percent a year (26 U.S.C. 4942); the donor-advised fund post compares the two.
Own the thing that grows
- Founder stock. Qualified small business stock issued after July 4, 2025 can exclude up to $15 million of gain, in steps at three, four and five years (26 U.S.C. 1202; covered in the quant desks post).
- Opportunity zones, rebuilt by the 2025 law: for money invested after 2026, gains are deferred five years with a 10 percent basis increase, 30 percent in rural funds, and appreciation after ten years is excluded (26 U.S.C. 1400Z-2).
- Pass-through owners keep the 20 percent qualified business income deduction, now permanent (26 U.S.C. 199A).
Self-directed retirement accounts, carefully
An IRA can own real estate, private loans and other alternative assets; it cannot own collectibles or life insurance (IRS). But buying from, lending to or using the property yourself, or with close family, is a prohibited transaction that ends the IRA as of January 1 of that year (IRS). Borrowed money inside an IRA creates taxable debt-financed income, while a 401(k) trust, including a solo 401(k), has a real estate exception the IRA lacks (26 U.S.C. 514(c)(9)). The SEC warns that custodians "will generally not evaluate the quality or legitimacy of an investment and its promoters" (SEC and NASAA alert).
What not to copy
The individual version of the hospital captive is the micro-captive, and it is the one the IRS has targeted. The IRS made certain small captive arrangements listed transactions in January 2025 (T.D. 10029), and said in 2024 that it "has prevailed in all micro-captive Tax Court and appellate court cases decided on their merits since 2017" (IRS). Syndicated conservation easements are also listed transactions, and the 2026 Dirty Dozen warns about inflated appraisals of donated easements and art (IRS).
Private funds, if you qualify
The private equity and hedge funds the institutions buy are generally sold to accredited investors: net worth over $1 million excluding your home, or income over $200,000 single or $300,000 joint (SEC). Interval funds open some of those strategies to everyone, but they repurchase only 5 to 25 percent of shares at a time, often quarterly, and some charge higher fees (SEC investor bulletin). A Labor Department rule to ease private assets into 401(k) plans was proposed in March 2026 and is not final (Federal Register).
What the record does not show
- Which captives elected to be taxed as U.S. companies, and how much excise tax any of them paid.
- Whether any captive's reserves are invested in its parent's main investment pool; no statement I read says so.
- Kaiser's and Intermountain's audited statements, which are posted only on the municipal bond disclosure site, which refused my reads.
- Fund-level holdings and the fees taken inside the funds.
Related reading
- Tax-Free Returns on Public Money: part 1, the portfolios and the public money.
- Who Gets Paid When a Nonprofit Hospital Pays No Tax: part 2, vendors, managers, bondholders and insiders.
- Fiat Lux, a university's captive insurer: one captive, up close.
- Other People's Money: insurance float as an investment engine.
- Family offices explained: the structure this last section is the alternative to.
The thread through all three parts, that the advantages compound for whoever owns the asset, is the subject of The W-2 Trap.
Fact-check notes and sources
- Schedule R figures (captive names, domiciles, income, assets, ownership, filing type, Part V transactions): each organization's newest Form 990 in the IRS e-file data release; return list and fiscal years in part 1. Transaction types use the codes on Schedule R. Country code CJ is the Cayman Islands and BD is Bermuda. Totals are my sums.
- Audited statements: CommonSpirit FY2026, Trinity FY2026 and FY2025, Ascension FY2026, Cleveland Clinic 2025, UPMC 2025, Northwestern FY2025, Mass General Brigham FY2025 and Advocate Aurora Health 2025, linked in the text with note numbers where given.
- Market data: CIMA insurance statistics, third quarter 2026; Vermont DFR 2023 aggregate report, unaudited.
- Tax law: statutes at Cornell LII as linked; H. Rept. 104-586; Rev. Proc. 2003-47; Rev. Rul. 78-41; PLR 200501017, which has no precedential value.
- Reserves and medians: KFF, Health Affairs abstract and Fierce summary, Fitch via HFMA and Fierce, Moody's via Becker's, as linked. Endowments: NACUBO-Commonfund FY2025 public tables. Nonprofit assets: Federal Reserve Z.1, table S15.b, release of September 11, 2026.
- 2026 individual figures: IRS news releases IR-2025-111 and IR-2025-103, Notice 2025-67, Rev. Proc. 2025-19, Rev. Proc. 2025-32, Notice 2026-5, and the statutes as linked. Municipal holdings: MSRB, read from an archived copy because msrb.org refused direct reads.
This post is informational, not legal, tax or investment advice. Rules have limits and exceptions not covered here; check your own situation with a qualified professional. Figures are reproduced from public filings and public records as of the dates given. Organizations are discussed from the public record as nominative fair use, with no affiliation implied.